Trustpilot
Spend $150 plus: 20% discount at checkout. Spend $100 - 15% discount.

Personalized pencils on demand - how does it work?

Step 1

Choose your favorite product, color, and quantity

Step 2

Customize your pencil with texts and/or artwork

Step 3

Add to cart, finish the checkout, Done! We will email virtual proof for your review.

Personalized Imprinted Pencils from Pencil Guy Shop

Looking for a simple personalized favor to top off the place settings at your wedding? Or an easy way to keep your business’ name in the mind of potential clients at your next trade show? Or even a great gift for your students at school?

At Pencil Guy Shop, we believe there’s an inherent joy in receiving and using a pencil with a message. That’s why we make our custom promotional pencils available to our customers for the lowest prices and with the fastest turnaround on the market. Whether you need 200 or 2,000 imprinted pencils for your event in one day or one month, we’ll take care of everything you need!

Premium Quality Custom Pencils in Bulk - Lowest Priced Customized Pencil Online!

Our specialty is pencils. That means we don’t have to split our efforts to imprint an overwhelming variety of different products and can instead put all of our focus into providing the most high-quality pencil options for the best value.

Imprinted pencils are available in bulk orders as small as 144 or as large as 20,000, with a custom logo, artwork, or text. Upon request, we will provide a free virtual proof for your approval before we set to work completing your order, to ensure everything is exactly to your liking. All pencil products are also available blank, and sharpened or unsharpened.

Exceptional Customer Service for Your Custom Pencil Order - Chat with Brian

Here at Pencil Guy Shop, we pride ourselves not only on our first-rate products and competitive prices, but also the high-quality customer service we provide with every purchase.

We work quickly and efficiently to meet any deadline, and even offer one day or same day shipping for any order! Check out our 5-star reviews below to learn more about how we go above and beyond to make sure your experience with us is a great one.

Pencil Guy - Amazon -  4.9 Star Feedback Rating!

Psst! Do you know that we are on Amazon? Same products, same service. So if you prefer the Amazon shopping experience, please feel free to search for Pencil Guy on Amazon. (p.s. Pricing is lower on pencilguyshop.com) 

Check out our reviews on Amazon: Amazon Pencil Guy Reviews and visit our store at Pencil Guy Shop 

Browse our catalog of promotional personalized pencils to find the perfect color, size, style, and customizable design to fit your needs. To discuss a specific request for your custom imprinted pencil order, email us at Brian@Pencilguyshop.com, or give us a call at 800-516-2379!

See what our customers have to say:

  • Brian was so great to work with - I was procrastinating as usual and asked for info on a friday night - not expecting a response until Monday morning. Not only did Brian answer my questions on a friday night but also set up my proofs and took my order that night also ! They were delivered that Wed. and are PERFECT. THANK YOU SO MUCH

    Shannon | Cedarburg, WI | 11/09/23

  • My son came home from school on a Tuesday asking if we could make pencils to hand out for a school election on Friday. I found pencilguyshop.com and placed an order Tuesday late afternoon, then emails and asked if it could be produced and shipped for delivery on Thursday. It was not a problem and the items shipped by 10:00am on Wednesday for overnight delivery. Brian is great. Really appreciate the job done!

    Matthew | Ashburn, VA | 10/11/23

  • This company went above and beyond to accommodate me as I initially ordered the wrong quantity. After placing a second order they turned it around the very same day and I had it within just a few days. I highly recommend the Pencil Guy for his excellent customer service.

    Mary | Peoria, AZ | 08/24/23

  • Third time I’ve bought my scholar pencils from him! Amazing seller! Amazing product! The BEST!

    Robin - Panama City, FL - 07/25/23

  • I ordered 144 custom pencils for my classroom with my name and course on them in hopes fewer walk out the door this school year. The price was fair, the pencils are good quality, the pencil color and letter printing are clean, crisp, and clear. I choose dark green pencils with gold text. They look lovely. Can’t wait to use them! Brian, the owner/maker was extremely responsive and initiated great communication to ensure the proof was approved, to ask when I needed them by, and to let me know when they were on their way. I received them in a pretty quick turnaround time. Would recommend and will likely order from the Pencil Shop Guy again.

    Lindsay - Washington, MO - 07/16/23

  • 5.0 out of 5 stars Awesome, awesome, awesome! I cannot say enough good things about this entire experience. We misplaced a box of personalized pencils that we give out to our AP Calculus students and we only had a little over a week to replace them before the exam. To get a custom product in such a short amount of time is a miracle in itself. Such great communication the whole way through. Quick responses and quick proof. I didn’t think we were going to be able to replace them in time and they came today (with days to spare) and they are perfect!

    Karen | Farmingdale, NY| 5/03/23

Brian was so great to work with - I was procrastinating as usual and asked for info on a friday night - not expecting a response until Monday morning. Not only did Brian answer my questions on a friday night but also set up my proofs and took my order that night also ! They were delivered that Wed. and are PERFECT. THANK YOU SO MUCH

Shannon | Cedarburg, WI | 11/09/23

My son came home from school on a Tuesday asking if we could make pencils to hand out for a school election on Friday. I found pencilguyshop.com and placed an order Tuesday late afternoon, then emails and asked if it could be produced and shipped for delivery on Thursday. It was not a problem and the items shipped by 10:00am on Wednesday for overnight delivery. Brian is great. Really appreciate the job done!

Matthew | Ashburn, VA | 10/11/23

This company went above and beyond to accommodate me as I initially ordered the wrong quantity. After placing a second order they turned it around the very same day and I had it within just a few days. I highly recommend the Pencil Guy for his excellent customer service.

Mary | Peoria, AZ | 08/24/23

Third time I’ve bought my scholar pencils from him! Amazing seller! Amazing product! The BEST!

Robin - Panama City, FL - 07/25/23

I ordered 144 custom pencils for my classroom with my name and course on them in hopes fewer walk out the door this school year. The price was fair, the pencils are good quality, the pencil color and letter printing are clean, crisp, and clear. I choose dark green pencils with gold text. They look lovely. Can’t wait to use them! Brian, the owner/maker was extremely responsive and initiated great communication to ensure the proof was approved, to ask when I needed them by, and to let me know when they were on their way. I received them in a pretty quick turnaround time. Would recommend and will likely order from the Pencil Shop Guy again.

Lindsay - Washington, MO - 07/16/23

5.0 out of 5 stars Awesome, awesome, awesome! I cannot say enough good things about this entire experience. We misplaced a box of personalized pencils that we give out to our AP Calculus students and we only had a little over a week to replace them before the exam. To get a custom product in such a short amount of time is a miracle in itself. Such great communication the whole way through. Quick responses and quick proof. I didn’t think we were going to be able to replace them in time and they came today (with days to spare) and they are perfect!

Karen | Farmingdale, NY| 5/03/23