Personalized pencils on demand - how does it work?

Step 1

Choose your favorite product, color and quantity

Step 2

Customize your pencil with texts and/or artwork

Step 3

Add to cart, finish the checkout, Done! We will email virtual proof for your review.

Featured Products

Personalized Imprinted Pencils from Pencil Guy Shop

Looking for a simple personalized favor to top off the place settings at your wedding? Or an easy way to keep your business’ name in the mind of potential clients at your next trade show? Or even a great gift for your students at school?

At Pencil Guy Shop, we believe there’s an inherent joy in receiving and using a pencil with a message. That’s why we make our custom promotional pencils available to our customers for the lowest prices and with the fastest turnaround on the market. Whether you need 200 or 2,000 imprinted pencils for your event in one day or one month, we’ll take care of everything you need!

Premium Quality Custom Pencils in Bulk - Lowest Priced Customized Pencil Online!

Our specialty is pencils. That means we don’t have to split our efforts to imprint an overwhelming variety of different products and can instead put all of our focus into providing the most high-quality pencil options for the best value.

Imprinted pencils are available in bulk orders as small as 144 or as large as 20,000, with a custom logo, artwork, or text. Upon request, we will provide a free virtual proof for your approval before we set to work completing your order, to ensure everything is exactly to your liking. All pencil products are also available blank, and sharpened or unsharpened.

Exceptional Customer Service for Your Custom Pencil Order - Chat with Brian

Here at Pencil Guy Shop, we pride ourselves not only on our first-rate products and competitive prices, but also the high-quality customer service we provide with every purchase.

We work quickly and efficiently to meet any deadline, and even offer one day or same day shipping for any order! Check out our 5-star reviews below to learn more about how we go above and beyond to make sure your experience with us is a great one.

Pencil Guy - Amazon -  4.9 Star Feedback Rating!

Psst! Do you know that we are on Amazon? Same products, same service. So if you prefer the Amazon shopping experience, please feel free to search for Pencil Guy on Amazon. (p.s. Pricing is lower on pencilguyshop.com) 

Check out our reviews on Amazon: Amazon Pencil Guy Reviews and visit our store at Pencil Guy Shop 

Browse our catalog of promotional personalized pencils to find the perfect color, size, style, and customizable design to fit your needs. To discuss a specific request for your custom imprinted pencil order, email us at Brian@Pencilguyshop.com, or give us a call at 516-642-4037!

See what our customers have to say:

  • I literally cried seeing my vision come to life .. I thank you for your work. I will be ordering more soon. I love them so much!!!

    LaToya | East Point, GA | 06/28/22

  • I'm not usually one to do reviews except when the interaction with the seller warrants a review. To say that I'm very impressed by this vendor is an understatement. Great communication, quick turn time, and a quality product to boot. That's the trifecta of a successful retail transaction. Color me impressed!

    Kathy | Dubuque, IA | 06/25/22

  • Brian was so thorough. He really went above and beyond to make sure my pencils printed correctly. Really fast response time and great pricing! Thank you pencil guy! Will definitely use again in the future.

    Lexi- Alpine, CA - 06/19/2022

  • Pencil Guy Shop is a fantastic company! They have excellent customer service, and are able to rush orders if you ask. I ordered pencils from them last year, and they were excellent quality. I just ordered some more for a school event, and a representative contacted me within minutes after I asked for my order to be shipped out the next business day. I would recommend Pencil Guy Shop to anyone needing high quality promotional pencils and good customer service at a reasonable price.

    Guy - East Greenwich, RI - 6/05/22

  • I called The Pencil Guy Shop after spending plenty of time looking for personalized pencils that would arrive on time. Nothing worked until I found Brian. He helped me with the design, sent a visual of how it would look before I placed the order, and charged less than any other place I researched, And, the pencils arrived as he said they would. Nice to deal with small business!

    Deborah | Tinley Park, IL | 5/20/22

  • Awesome customer service, product and speed. We wanted pencils for a ballet performance event and at first I wasn't going to personalize them. But, decided to and of course then wanted to change the color. All I had to do was open a chat - it was all taken care of for me, order processed and shipped very quickly and the quality is perfect. Very reasonable as well. Highly recommend!!!

    Margaret | Willimastown, NJ | 05/05/22

I literally cried seeing my vision come to life .. I thank you for your work. I will be ordering more soon. I love them so much!!!

LaToya | East Point, GA | 06/28/22

I'm not usually one to do reviews except when the interaction with the seller warrants a review. To say that I'm very impressed by this vendor is an understatement. Great communication, quick turn time, and a quality product to boot. That's the trifecta of a successful retail transaction. Color me impressed!

Kathy | Dubuque, IA | 06/25/22

Brian was so thorough. He really went above and beyond to make sure my pencils printed correctly. Really fast response time and great pricing! Thank you pencil guy! Will definitely use again in the future.

Lexi- Alpine, CA - 06/19/2022

Pencil Guy Shop is a fantastic company! They have excellent customer service, and are able to rush orders if you ask. I ordered pencils from them last year, and they were excellent quality. I just ordered some more for a school event, and a representative contacted me within minutes after I asked for my order to be shipped out the next business day. I would recommend Pencil Guy Shop to anyone needing high quality promotional pencils and good customer service at a reasonable price.

Guy - East Greenwich, RI - 6/05/22

I called The Pencil Guy Shop after spending plenty of time looking for personalized pencils that would arrive on time. Nothing worked until I found Brian. He helped me with the design, sent a visual of how it would look before I placed the order, and charged less than any other place I researched, And, the pencils arrived as he said they would. Nice to deal with small business!

Deborah | Tinley Park, IL | 5/20/22

Awesome customer service, product and speed. We wanted pencils for a ballet performance event and at first I wasn't going to personalize them. But, decided to and of course then wanted to change the color. All I had to do was open a chat - it was all taken care of for me, order processed and shipped very quickly and the quality is perfect. Very reasonable as well. Highly recommend!!!

Margaret | Willimastown, NJ | 05/05/22